- "The Manganos gave you a chance and you fucked up."
- ―Paulo Riccitello[src]
Following the takeover of Global Storage in Miami by Dominic and his made men, Paulo was sent to meet with Dominic, who was under the impression he was to be attending a sitdown with Samuele. Paulo informed Dominic that his betrayal would cost him his life, and the two argued. However, a fire-fight erupted, and Paulo apparently fled, while his men seized many of Dominic's businesses in Miami.
Paulo met his end when Dominic and his made men stormed and blew up the Mangano Compound, eliminating the family.
Behind the scenes
He was voiced by Joe Paulino.
- Paulo doesn't appear at the Mangano Compound yet is listed as being killed following its destruction.
- Paulo is the only rival consigliere to be seen in the game outside the Don's View.
- It is worth noting the Mangano consigliere that is featured on the Mangano hit sheet: his appearance differs from the man who claimed to be Paulo at the warehouse meeting with Dominic earlier in the game. This could either mean that the man at the meeting was merely an associate claiming to be Paulo, or that enough time had passed between the meeting and the fall of the Mangano Compound for Paulo's looks to change. More likely however is that this is a mistake made by the developers.